This is a ‘love it’ or ‘hate it’ film. Like this reviewer, a small fraction of the audience will find themselves in between. The general public will either love this or hate it, depending on their expectations in comparing this film to Kick-Ass and it will always be compared to Kick-Ass. Both films are about ordinary people donning costumes to fight crime. However, this is where the comparison ends. Written and directed by James Gunn, this is not a movie for just anyone. Keeping in mind his Dawn of the Dead and Slither, it becomes evident that Gunn has intended for this film to target a specific segment of the movie going populace, specifically those who enjoy very dark humour.
A cook by profession, Frank D’Arbo (Rainn Wilson) is a sad man with a depressing past and a feeble excuse of an existence. His greatest moments in life is marrying a recovering drug addict, Sarah (Liv Tyler) and helping a cop catch a purse snatcher. These events are so overwhelming that Frank even symbolizes its meaning through crayon sketches. Then things turn sour again. Sarah relapses into drug addiction and even leaves Frank for Jacques (Kevin Bacon), her drug dealer. Attempts to get his wife back results in insults and beatings, until the day Frank has an epiphany. Having realized that the only way to recuperate his wife is to punish drug pushers, Frank becomes a furious vigilante, and soon gains media attention as “The Crimson Bolt”.
As an independent production, Super has its moments as a believable and funny film, with some good acting from top actors. Although the plot, acting, and twisted humour are the highlights of the film, it never comes together as a whole. Like Kick-Ass, the story pits average Joes as superheroes but without super powers. But unlike the aforementioned film, the vigilantes here are almost psychopathic. And yes, there is more than one. Last seen together in Juno, Ellen Page joins Frank as “Boltie”, a sensuous side-kick bordering on lunacy. Together, they are more dangerous than the sleaziest of dark alley crooks. As actors, both D’Arbo and Page are scary, funny and insane. In opposing roles are Kevin Bacon and Michael Rooker as his side-kick. Bacon is the same as in all his antagonistic roles, 80 percent threat and 20 percent deed. My biggest disappointment is the underplayed role of Liv Tyler. Gorgeous as she is, Tyler’s role (and character) is a negligible two pennies worth that could have been done without.
Coming back to Gunn and his attempt in making an off-beat, albeit, dark comedy, I can say his approach is acceptable in starting an offshoot in the superhero genre. By his words, there are thousands of bank heist movies, so why not a few movies about superheroes without super powers.
If you haven’t seen Kick-Ass, I would suggest you watch that film first. If by then you are ready for some in-your-face violence (literally), a twisted and absurdly dark plot with a questionable conclusion, then, and only then would I suggest you try this movie. But don’t say you weren’t warned. In not calling it tasteless, this film does have a certain odd taste to it. It’s like curiously savouring a medium-rare steak and then wondering halfway “what if the meat is human flesh!?!”
Rating: 
